THE GREEN TRANSITION IS A STRATEGIC FRONTIER

23 Nov 2026

Tags: Science & Technology   S&T Developments   Modern technology

Source: The Indian Express

Context: India's transition towards clean energy is creating new economic and strategic dependencies, particularly on China for critical minerals, solar components and battery technologies. The article argues that energy security and strategic autonomy in the 21st century require domestic clean-technology manufacturing capabilities and diversified supply chains.

Green Transition and Emerging Strategic Dependencies

  • Changing dimensions of national security: The transition from fossil fuels to clean energy is shifting industrial and strategic power towards countries controlling critical minerals, battery technologies, solar manufacturing and energy-storage systems. China has emerged as a dominant player in this sector.
  • India's export restriction on battery black mass (November 10): India prohibited exports of lithium-ion battery black mass, a material recovered from used batteries containing lithium, cobalt, nickel and manganese, to retain it for domestic refining and value addition.
  • Domestic mineral-processing initiative: The Union Cabinet approved a ₹2,814-crore scheme for four domestic lithium and nickel processing plants, aimed at strengthening domestic processing capabilities.

China's Dominance in Clean Technology Supply Chains

  • Solar manufacturing: China controls approximately 82% of global solar-module manufacturing capacity, 91% of solar-cell capacity and 95% of wafer capacity.
  • Battery and mineral processing: China accounts for around 80% of global lithium-ion battery capacity and over 70% of cobalt and lithium processing.
  • Wider technological control: Its dominance extends to solar inverters, electricity-grid equipment and energy-storage systems, reflecting decades of state-directed industrial policy.
  • Technology as an instrument of geopolitical influence: China's proposed export restrictions on advanced photovoltaic technologies, including silicon-wafer manufacturing, demonstrate how control over critical technologies can be used for economic and strategic pressure.

India's Vulnerability in Clean Technology

  • Dependence despite domestic incentives: Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes promote domestic solar-module and Advanced Chemistry Cell (ACC) manufacturing, but India remains structurally dependent on Chinese imports.
  • Gaps in solar manufacturing: India's solar-module manufacturing capacity exceeds its domestic production capabilities in solar cells and wafers, creating dependence on imported upstream components.
  • EV and battery dependence: India's electric-vehicle and battery industries rely on Chinese cells, components and critical-mineral processing.
  • Limitations of diplomatic partnerships: Cooperation through the Quad and strategic partnerships with the U.S. cannot substitute for India's own technological capabilities and manufacturing ecosystem.

Measures to Strengthen India's Strategic Autonomy

  • Strengthening domestic value addition: PLI schemes must be supplemented with sustained investments in upstream manufacturing, chemistry, metallurgy and materials science. The success of the ₹2,814-crore processing scheme will depend on timely commissioning, assured mineral supplies and domestic technological expertise.
  • Securing critical minerals through international partnerships: India should establish long-term investment and supply partnerships with resource-rich countries such as Chile, Argentina, the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Indonesia, Zambia and Zimbabwe. Cooperation should extend to mineral processing and manufacturing rather than being restricted to raw-material extraction.
  • National Critical Mineral Mission (2025): Aims to strengthen India's critical-mineral supply chains through domestic exploration, mining, processing, recycling and overseas mineral acquisition.
  • Khanij Bidesh India Limited (KABIL): A joint venture of three public sector enterprises established to acquire and develop strategic overseas mineral assets. Its five lithium brine blocks in Argentina are currently at the exploration stage.
  • Technological multi-alignment: India should diversify its technological options by developing alternatives such as sodium-ion batteries, solid-state batteries and green hydrogen alongside conventional lithium-ion technologies.
  • Promoting research and innovation: Technological leadership requires translating research into commercial production through patient capital, industry-academia partnerships, skilled manpower and predictable domestic demand, including public procurement.
  • Scaling up recycling: India should develop large-scale recycling and refining capabilities for used batteries, solar panels and electronic waste to recover critical minerals and reduce import dependence.
  • International technological cooperation: India should collaborate with technologically advanced countries in research, manufacturing and the development of common standards governing clean technologies.

Strategic Implications for India

  • Avoiding replacement of one dependency with another: The Ukraine crisis demonstrated how dependence on energy pipelines can become a strategic vulnerability. India risks replacing its dependence on West Asian fossil fuels with dependence on Chinese clean-technology supply chains.
  • Energy security as national security: Reliable access to critical minerals, batteries and clean-energy technologies is essential for India's economic resilience and strategic independence.
  • Beyond conventional military strength: National sovereignty in the 21st century will increasingly depend on control over critical technologies, industrial capabilities and resilient supply chains, alongside traditional military power.

Relevant Concepts for UPSC

  • Critical Minerals
    • Meaning: Minerals essential for economic development and national security, whose supply chains are vulnerable to disruption due to geographical concentration or limited availability.
    • Examples: Lithium, cobalt, nickel, graphite, copper and rare earth elements.
    • Applications: Electric vehicles, batteries, renewable energy, electronics, defence equipment and semiconductor manufacturing.
  • Battery Black Mass
    • Meaning: Powder-like material obtained after dismantling and mechanically processing spent lithium-ion batteries.
    • Composition: Contains valuable metals such as lithium, cobalt, nickel and manganese.
    • Significance: Acts as an important secondary source of critical minerals for recycling and domestic refining.

Key Battery Technologies

TechnologyKey feature
Lithium-ionHigh energy density; widely used in EVs
Sodium-ionUses abundant sodium; potential alternative to lithium
Solid-stateUses solid electrolyte; offers potential improvements in safety and energy density