ALL-TOO FALLIBLE: DEATH PENALTY AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE

19 Nov 2026

Tags: Governance   Policy Interventions   Sectoral development schemes

Source: The Hindu

Context: India voted against a proposed global moratorium on the death penalty at the United Nations (UN), consistent with its position that capital punishment is a sovereign decision subject to judicial safeguards.

  • India's stand: Retains the death penalty, citing judicial safeguards, the “rarest of rare” doctrine and mandatory High Court confirmation of death sentences awarded by trial courts.
  • Judicial approach: The Supreme Court has increasingly restricted the imposition of capital punishment.
  • Deterrence debate: Research has failed to establish that the death penalty provides greater deterrence than life imprisonment.
  • Judicial vs extrajudicial killings: India distinguishes legally sanctioned executions following due process from extrajudicial killings, although the effectiveness of safeguards remains contested.

Concerns Regarding the Death Penalty

  • Penal populism: Expansion of capital offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), particularly in response to public outrage over sexual violence, may reflect politically appealing punitive measures rather than effective criminal justice reform.
  • Weak deterrence: Poor policing, weak investigations and low conviction rates undermine deterrence, which cannot be achieved merely through harsher punishments.
  • Rising death-row population: India had 574 prisoners on death row as of December 31, 2025, the highest since 2016, reflecting the growing number of death sentences awarded by trial courts.
  • Fallibility of justice: False testimony, flawed evidence, wrongful convictions and inadequate legal representation can result in irreversible miscarriages of justice.
  • Unequal access to justice: Poor and vulnerable accused persons may lack access to competent legal representation, increasing the risk of unfair convictions and sentencing.

Evidence Against Capital Punishment

  • Wrongful convictions: The Supreme Court released 38 death-row prisoners during 2016–2025, according to Project 39A; these prisoners had spent an average of eight years on death row, with some spending over two decades.
  • Irreversibility: Unlike other punishments, execution cannot be undone if a conviction is subsequently found wrongful.
  • Deterrence concerns: Evidence does not conclusively establish that capital punishment deters crime more effectively than life imprisonment.
  • Disproportionate punishment: Extremely harsh punishment for non-fatal offences may incentivise offenders to escalate violence, including killing witnesses, to avoid detection.

Law Commission's Position

  • Law Commission Report, 2015: The report, headed by Justice A.P. Shah, concluded that the death penalty fails to achieve constitutionally valid penological goals.
  • Recommendation: Favoured abolition of the death penalty for all offences except terrorism-related offences and waging war against the State.
  • Rationale: Emphasised the need to reconsider capital punishment in light of constitutional principles, its deterrent value and the possibility of judicial error.

Why the Death Penalty is Problematic?

  • Fallible criminal justice system: Capital punishment requires a near-infallible system, but investigation, evidence collection, prosecution and judicial processes remain vulnerable to error.
  • Procedural safeguards are insufficient: High Court confirmation and the rarest-of-rare doctrine cannot completely eliminate wrongful convictions or unequal sentencing.
  • Socio-economic inequality: Access to quality legal representation can significantly influence the outcome of capital cases.
  • Human rights concerns: Raises questions concerning the right to life, human dignity and the possibility of irreversible punishment following judicial error.

Way Forward

  • Moratorium: Formally suspend executions to reassess the death penalty and its administration.
  • Legislative review: Review capital-punishment provisions and remove the death penalty for offences not involving intentional killing.
  • Abolition: Move towards abolition of capital punishment in law.
  • Criminal justice reforms: Strengthen investigation, forensic capacity, prosecution quality and evidence-based policing.
  • Legal aid: Ensure effective and competent legal representation for every person facing capital punishment.
  • Focus on certainty of justice: Improve the certainty, fairness and timeliness of punishment rather than relying on severity alone.

Prelims Question

Q1. With reference to the death penalty in India, consider the following statements:

  1. A death sentence awarded by a Sessions Court is subject to confirmation by the High Court before it can be executed.
  2. Under the rarest of rare doctrine, the death penalty should be imposed only when the alternative option of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.
  3. The Supreme Court has held that the death penalty is unconstitutional in India because it violates Article 21 in all circumstances.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

(a) 1 only
(b) 1 and 2 only
(c) 2 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer: (b) 

Explanation:

  • Statement 1 is Correct: Under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), a death sentence awarded by a Sessions Court must be submitted to the High Court for confirmation. The corresponding framework is now governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
  • Statement 2 is Correct: The rarest of rare doctrine, evolved in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980), restricts capital punishment to exceptional cases where life imprisonment is inadequate.
  • Statement 3 is Incorrect: The Supreme Court has not declared the death penalty unconstitutional in all circumstances. It remains constitutionally valid, subject to strict judicial safeguards.