ELUSIVE PEACE IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

19 Nov 2026

Tags: Polity & Constitution   Federal Dynamics   Devolution of powers

Source: The Hindu

Context: After nearly three months of relative calm, a series of violent incidents in Jammu and Kashmir has disrupted the security situation, raising concerns about the sustainability of peace.

  • Kulgam attack (November 11): Terrorists attacked a checkpoint manned by the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), injuring three personnel.
  • Kulgam anti-terror operation (November 16): A local suspected of joining terrorist ranks was killed after a six-day security operation in residential areas.
  • Kishtwar killings: Two Special Police Officers (SPOs) of J&K Police were found dead with bullet wounds after going missing in a forest area on November 11; circumstances surrounding their deaths remain unclear.

Concerns Over Security Operations

  • Civilian impact: The prolonged anti-terror operation in residential areas of Kulgam raised concerns about restrictions and inconvenience faced by civilians.
  • Political criticism: Former Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti termed the operation collective punishment, arguing that it could deepen alienation and resentment.
  • Restrictions in villages: National Conference spokesperson Imran Nabi Dar alleged that entire villages faced prolonged restrictions during the operation.
  • Governance constraints: The Omar Abdullah-led government has limited powers, particularly as police and public order remain under the Union Government in Jammu and Kashmir, a Union Territory since 2019.

Security Situation in Jammu & Kashmir

  • Decline in terrorism: The security-focused approach has contributed to a decline in terror attacks and local terrorist recruitment.
  • Local recruitment: According to the police, local recruitment into terrorist groups in Kashmir has fallen to single digits or fewer than 10.
  • Peace vs. silence: A decline in attacks and visible street disturbances cannot necessarily be equated with lasting peace, as political alienation and psychological distress may persist.

Why Restoration of Statehood is Important?

  • Democratic empowerment: Restoration of statehood would strengthen the authority of elected representatives and reinforce public confidence in democratic institutions.
  • Political accountability: It would enable the elected government to exercise greater control over governance and address regional concerns more effectively.
  • Public participation: It would reinforce the belief that participation in the 2024 Assembly elections can translate into meaningful political authority.
  • Reducing alienation: Political engagement and greater autonomy in governance could help address grievances and prevent resentment from turning into renewed instability.

Way Forward

  • Political outreach: The Centre should engage with diverse stakeholders in Jammu and Kashmir and fulfil its commitment to restore Statehood.
  • Balanced counter-terrorism: Security agencies must continue combating Pakistan-backed terrorism without causing unnecessary hardship or alienation among civilians.
  • Complementary approaches: Political reconciliation and security operations should reinforce each other rather than operate in conflict.
  • Strengthen elected institutions: Allow the political leadership to function effectively while enabling security agencies to address terrorism within the framework of law.

Mains Question

Q. “A decline in terrorist incidents does not necessarily signify the restoration of lasting peace in Jammu and Kashmir.” Discuss. Examine the role of democratic empowerment, political reconciliation and civilian-sensitive security measures in achieving sustainable peace in the region. (250 words)

Approach

Introduction: A decline in terrorism and violence indicates improved security, but sustainable peace requires political legitimacy, public trust and social reconciliation.

Body

1. Security gains and emerging concerns

  • Decline in terrorist incidents and local recruitment reflects improved security conditions.
  • Recent incidents indicate that the threat of terrorism persists.
  • Prolonged security operations and restrictions may affect civilian life and deepen alienation.

2. Why security-centric peace may be insufficient

  • Absence of violence may not reflect genuine public confidence or political satisfaction.
  • Limited powers of the elected government constrain democratic accountability.
  • Alienation, unemployment, political distrust and perceived exclusion may sustain underlying grievances.

3. Role of democratic empowerment and reconciliation

  • Restoration of Statehood can strengthen elected institutions and public participation.
  • Political dialogue with diverse stakeholders can address grievances and rebuild trust.
  • Civilian-sensitive counter-terrorism measures can prevent security operations from inadvertently generating resentment.

4. Way forward

  • Combine intelligence-led counter-terrorism with respect for human rights and civilian dignity.
  • Restore democratic autonomy and strengthen representative institutions.
  • Promote employment, development, community engagement and rehabilitation.
  • Pursue sustained political dialogue alongside security measures.

Conclusion: Lasting peace in Jammu and Kashmir requires a shift from managing violence to building trust. Security, democratic legitimacy and political reconciliation must operate as complementary pillars of peace.