HOW DOES INDIA ADDRESS SERVICE OUTAGES?

18 Nov 2026

Tags: Internal Security   Cyber & Media   Network risks

Source: The Hindu

Context: The global Microsoft 365 outage (November 12–13) disrupted access to Outlook and other productivity services worldwide, affecting Indian organisations, including IndiGo, Akasa Air and Air India. The incident highlighted gaps in India's regulatory framework regarding reporting, accountability and compensation for major digital service outages.

Regulatory Framework in India: Three major legal and regulatory frameworks are relevant, but each has certain limitations.

  • CERT-In Directions, 2022
    • Legal Basis: Issued by the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In) under the Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000, on April 28, 2022.
    • Reporting Requirement: Entities covered by the directions must report specified cyber incidents to CERT-In within 6 hours of noticing them or being informed about them.
    • Limitation: Covers cyberattacks, intrusions and other specified cyber incidents but does not explicitly cover service outages caused purely by technical faults.
    • Investigative Powers: Under Section 70B(6) of the IT Act, CERT-In can call for information and seek explanations from service providers, including Microsoft.
  • RBI Directions on Outsourcing of IT Services
    • Regulatory Framework: RBI's directions on managing risks in outsourcing of IT services, issued on November 28, 2025, carry forward the framework that initially took effect on October 1, 2023.
    • Applicability: Banks outsourcing IT services, including cloud services, must assess their dependence on service providers and establish appropriate risk-management mechanisms.
    • Exit Strategy: Banks must maintain an exit strategy to manage situations involving failure or disruption of outsourced services.
    • Accountability: RBI can hold the regulated bank responsible for outsourcing-related failures. The bank may seek explanations or remedies from Microsoft through contractual agreements.
    • Limitation: Accountability primarily rests on the regulated financial institution rather than imposing direct outage-reporting obligations on the cloud service provider.
  • Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023
    • Personal Data Breach: The Act includes accidental loss of access to personal data within the definition of a personal data breach.
    • Reporting Requirement: Under the Rules scheduled to come into effect in May 2027, personal data breaches must be reported to the Data Protection Board of India and affected individuals.
    • Penalty: Failure to fulfil breach-reporting obligations can attract a penalty of up to ₹200 crore.
    • Responsibility: The Data Fiduciary (organisation determining the purpose and means of processing personal data) bears the reporting responsibility, even when data is stored on a third-party cloud provider's servers.
    • Limitation: It remains unclear whether a temporary service outage amounts to a reportable personal data breach or merely a temporary interruption in access.

International Regulatory Frameworks for Cloud Service Outages

  • European Union (EU)
    • Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA): EU financial supervisors identified 19 critical third-party technology providers on November 18, 2025, including Microsoft and Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), for direct regulatory oversight.
    • Applicability: Direct oversight applies to technology providers whose services support financial entities.
    • NIS2 Directive: Provides a broader cybersecurity framework covering cloud service providers across sectors.
    • Incident Reporting: Under the October 2024 rules, a significant cloud-service incident includes:
      • Complete unavailability exceeding 30 minutes.
      • Partial failure lasting over one hour, affecting more than 5% or one million EU users, whichever threshold is lower.
    • Reporting Timeline: Initial notification within 24 hours and detailed notification within 72 hours to the competent national authority.
    • Significance: Reporting obligations are based on outage duration and the number of users affected, irrespective of whether the disruption resulted from a cyberattack or technical failure.
  • United Kingdom (UK)
  • Direct Oversight: As of July 13, 2026, the Bank of England had placed Microsoft and three other technology companies under its regulatory oversight.
  • Applicability: Covers critical technology services supplied to financial institutions.
  • Singapore
  • Digital Infrastructure Law: Passed on October 7, 2026.
  • Licensing: Requires large data centres and cloud service providers to obtain licences.
  • Reporting: Mandates reporting of service interruptions to the regulator.
  • South Korea
  • Background: A data-centre fire in October 2022 disrupted KakaoTalk, a widely used messaging platform.
  • Regulatory Response: Since July 2023, large digital platforms and data centres have been required to submit disaster-management plans to the government.
  • Objective: Improve preparedness and resilience against infrastructure failures.

India's Key Regulatory Gaps

  • Limited Incident Coverage: CERT-In's reporting framework focuses on specified cyber incidents rather than all major service disruptions.
  • Absence of Outage Thresholds: India lacks clearly defined thresholds based on outage duration, geographical spread and number of affected users.
  • Indirect Accountability: Cloud providers are primarily accountable through contractual arrangements, while sectoral regulators often hold the customer organisation responsible.
  • Ambiguity under DPDP Act: It is unclear whether temporary loss of access to personal data constitutes a reportable breach.
  • Lack of Uniform Framework: No comprehensive cross-sector mechanism clearly specifies who must report major outages, to which authority and within what timeframe.

Options Available to Indian Customers

  • Contractual Remedies: Customers can seek remedies under their agreements with Microsoft. If the agreed Service Level Agreement (SLA) is breached, they may receive service credits (discounts on future bills).
  • Limited Compensation: Such credits depend on contractual conditions and may not adequately compensate customers for broader operational losses.

Way Forward: Strengthening India's Digital Infrastructure Accountability

  • Expand CERT-In Reporting: Include major service disruptions arising from technical faults, infrastructure failures and cyberattacks within mandatory reporting requirements.
  • Direct Regulatory Oversight: Bring major digital service providers and critical cloud infrastructure companies under appropriate regulatory supervision.
  • Clarify DPDP Provisions: The Data Protection Board should clarify whether temporary outages constitute personal data breaches and specify reporting responsibilities.
  • Strengthen Domestic Alternatives: Reduce excessive dependence on foreign cloud and email service providers by developing reliable domestic digital infrastructure.
  • Disaster Resilience: Mandate business continuity plans, disaster recovery mechanisms, redundancy and periodic resilience testing for critical digital service providers.
  • Uniform Accountability: Establish clear rules specifying reporting authorities, timelines, outage thresholds and responsibilities of both service providers and customer organisations.

India's Move Towards Domestic Digital Infrastructure

  • Government Email Services: In December 2025, the Union government informed the Lok Sabha that 12.68 lakh official email accounts had shifted to a platform operated by Chennai-based Zoho.
  • Significance: Reduces dependence on foreign service providers and supports domestic digital infrastructure.
  • Remaining Gap: Domestic service providers are also not explicitly required under existing CERT-In directions to report purely technical service outages.

Important Concepts for UPSC

  • CERT-In (Indian Computer Emergency Response Team)
    • Established: 2004.
    • Nodal Ministry: Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY).
    • Legal Status: National agency for performing functions related to cyber incident response under Section 70B of the IT Act, 2000.
    • Functions: Collection and analysis of cyber incident information, incident response coordination, alerts, advisories and cybersecurity awareness.
    • Reporting: The 2022 directions require specified entities to report listed cyber incidents within six hours.
  • Cloud Computing
    • Delivery of computing resources such as servers, storage, databases, networking and software over the internet.
    • Enables organisations to access scalable computing infrastructure without maintaining all physical infrastructure themselves.
    • Major risks include service outages, data breaches, vendor dependence and data-security concerns.
  • Service Level Agreement (SLA)
    • A contractual agreement between a service provider and customer specifying expected service standards.
    • Includes uptime commitments, performance standards, maintenance conditions, incident response and remedies for service failure.
  • Digital Personal Data Protection Board of India
    • Statutory body established under the DPDP Act, 2023.
    • Responsible for determining non-compliance with the Act and imposing penalties.
    • Plays a key role in adjudicating personal data breach-related violations.