Context: India's participation in the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi, which Pakistan's Climate Minister Musadik Masood Malik is expected to attend, provides an opportunity to maintain diplomatic engagement with Pakistan despite bilateral tensions following the Pahalgam terror attack.
India's Position on Relations with Pakistan
- Post-Pahalgam Attack: India has maintained that terrorism and bilateral talks cannot coexist, linking normalisation of relations with Pakistan to an end to cross-border terrorism.
- Broader Restrictions: Prime Minister Narendra Modi extended this position to trade and water-related cooperation, making bilateral relations conditional on Pakistan addressing cross-border terrorism.
- Need for Engagement: India must maintain its firm position on terrorism while exploring cooperation in other areas of mutual interest.
Role of Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO)
- India's Initiative: India invited all SCO members to New Delhi for the Civilisational Dialogue Forum and participated in preparatory meetings ahead of the August 2027 Islamabad Summit.
- Pakistan's Participation: Pakistan is keeping diplomatic channels open during its SCO chairmanship by participating in an initiative promoted by India.
- Strategic Significance: Multilateral platforms provide opportunities for dialogue even when bilateral relations remain strained and help India maintain its regional diplomatic influence.
- Chinese Influence: According to Chatham House, strained relations between India and its neighbours have created diplomatic vacuums that China has utilised through regional and trilateral groupings.
Regional Water Security: Areas of Concern
- Geographical Interdependence: India is an upstream country for Pakistan and Bangladesh, but a downstream country for China, making regional water management dependent on cooperation among riparian countries.
- Indus River: India stopped sharing routine hydrological data relating to the Indus River and approved the Chenab-Beas link tunnel project. Pakistan's Climate Minister responded with threatening remarks over restrictions on its water share.
- Brahmaputra River: China has restricted sharing hydrological data with India while developing the Medog mega-dam in Tibet, raising concerns over downstream water security.
- Padma Barrage: India has protested Bangladesh's proposed Padma Barrage amid Bangladesh's increasing alignment with China. The editorial draws a parallel with India's construction of the Farakka Barrage in 1961 despite objections from East Pakistan.
- Climate Change Dimension: Climate change increases the need for regional cooperation to manage shared river systems, protect contested geographical regions, maintain border-community engagement and harness hydroelectric potential.
Importance of Regional Water Cooperation
- Water Security: Cooperation in sharing hydrological data, flood forecasting and river management can reduce water-related tensions.
- Disaster Management: Joint mechanisms can help manage floods, droughts and other climate-induced disasters.
- Energy Security: Coordinated development of hydropower resources can improve regional energy availability.
- Border Stability: Cooperation over shared resources can strengthen engagement among border populations and reduce regional tensions.
Challenges to India's Regional Leadership
- Low Regional Integration: South Asia is among the least economically integrated regions, with intra-regional trade accounting for only around 5% of total regional trade.
- Growing Chinese Influence: Deteriorating relations between India and neighbouring countries create opportunities for China to expand its influence through alternative regional and trilateral arrangements.
- Limitations of Isolation: Suspending bilateral engagement may demonstrate political resolve but does not necessarily weaken terrorist capabilities or improve India's security.
- Regional Leadership: India's ambition to emerge as a regional leader requires sustained engagement, including with difficult neighbours.
Way Forward
- Separate Cooperation from Disputes: Maintain a firm stance against terrorism while identifying mutually beneficial areas of cooperation.
- Strengthen Multilateral Platforms: Utilise the SCO and other regional institutions to sustain dialogue and build confidence.
- Water Diplomacy: Promote hydrological data-sharing, flood management and climate-resilient river-basin cooperation.
- Neighbourhood Engagement: Prevent diplomatic vacuums that allow external powers to expand their influence in South Asia.
- Cooperative Regionalism: Balance national security interests with regional interdependence in water, energy, trade and climate action.
Important Concepts for UPSC
- Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO)
- Established: 2001; evolved from the Shanghai Five mechanism.
- Nature: Eurasian political, economic and security organisation.
- Members: China, Russia, India, Pakistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Iran and Belarus.
- India and Pakistan: Became full members in 2017.
- Significance: Provides a platform for regional security cooperation, economic engagement and diplomatic dialogue.
- Riparian Countries: Countries sharing a river system or located along its course. Their upstream and downstream positions create interdependence in water allocation, hydrological data-sharing, flood management and hydropower development.
- Indus Waters Treaty (1960):
- Signed between India and Pakistan with the World Bank's involvement.
- Allocates the Eastern Rivers (Ravi, Beas and Sutlej) to India and the Western Rivers (Indus, Jhelum and Chenab) primarily to Pakistan, subject to specified Indian uses.
- Provides a framework for cooperation and dispute resolution over shared river waters.
- Farakka Barrage:
- Located across the Ganga in West Bengal.
- Commissioned in 1975 to divert water towards the Hooghly-Bhagirathi system to improve navigability and reduce siltation at Kolkata Port.
- Water-sharing became a major issue between India and Bangladesh; the Ganga Water Sharing Treaty was signed in 1996.
- Medog Mega-Dam:
- Proposed hydropower project on the Yarlung Tsangpo River in Tibet, which enters India as the Siang/Dihang and subsequently forms part of the Brahmaputra.
- Raises concerns regarding downstream water security, ecological impacts and India's strategic interests in the Northeast.